Join us on Linked InTel: 631.543.6363 Fax:631.543.4891
1030 Jericho Tpke. Smithtown, NY 11787

About Cafarelli Insurance Agency

The Cafarelli Agency Ltd. was established in 1985 by James A. Cafarelli and Barbara Cafarelli.  With a staff of 12 full-time producers in addition to a support team, we are a full service insurance agency licensed in the four states of New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, North Carolina and Florida. The Cafarelli Agency Ltd. specializes in providing professional services for all insurance needs, offering quality products to our clients backed by our strong commitment and professional integrity.


We represent many of the leading property, casualty, life and health carriers in the country including Travelers, CNA, Hanover, Progressive, Merchants Mutual, Utica National, Hartford and Tower Insurance. In addition to those direct carriers, Cafarelli Agency Ltd. has access to numerous specialty and excess markets. This allows us to offer the greatest quality of products and services at the most affordable rates for all insurance needs to more than 4,000 clients.


Our product and service lines also include residential and commercial real estate division. The addition of these divisions separates our agency from others and broadens our ability to offer complete, in-depth products and services that many other providers don’t have. To put it simple, Cafarelli Agency Ltd. offers one-stop shopping and professional service aimed toward making your experience with our office as comfortable as possible.