Join us on Linked InTel: 631.543.6363 Fax:631.543.4891
1030 Jericho Tpke. Smithtown, NY 11787

Contact Us

Please contact us with any questions or to get started immediately.

  Cafarelli Agency
  1030 Jericho Tpke
  Smithtown, NY 11787
  Fax: (631) 543-4891

  Our phone number is (631) 543-6363, please check the list below for extensions and e-mails of our entire staff:

Name Title Phone Ext. Email
James A Cafarelli President 200
Michael Chestaro Commercial Lines manager 202
Marie Marrone Personal Lines manager 208
Ronnie Keller Commercial lines CSR 204
Deidre Stanzer Commercial Lines CSR 215
Gabrielle Gerber Commercial Lines CSR 225
Jennifer Heiser Commercial Assistant 220
Steven Seguino Broker/Personal Lines 217
Jaclyn Cafarelli Personal Lines CSR 209
Katie Hayes Personal Lines Producer 227
JoAnn Karales Accounting Manager 201
Vincent Bitet Broker 206
Annette Bitet Broker 207
Chris Stoll Broker 210
Nick Devito Broker 205
Alan Wren Broker/Sales Director 216
Mary Lou Beska Account Representative  631-543-2205

We have added a new location in Mt. Sinai:

  Cafarelli DeVito Insurance Agency
  620 Route 25A, Suite C
  Mt. Sinai, NY 11766
  Phone: (631) 509-6388

  Fax: (631) 509-0088
  Contact: Nick DeVito